Scan the paper
Is the paper

Well written -- maybe too good?
(for the student in question)
- good command of vocabulary
- no spelling or grammatical errors
-great paper, but does not quite meet
the parameters of the assignment?
- are the citations complete and
uniform, but wrong citation style?

 Poorly written
-"stamp collector" paper that has
little logical flow
- paper does not meet the
parameters of the assignment
- old citations/ inappropriate
 references/ many "dead" links